Learning the truth behind food date labels, as explained in detail, can help you save money, reduce waste, and shop far more confidently.
Most shoppers assume “Best By,” “Sell By,” and “Use By” dates are strict safety deadlines, but in reality, these labels have nothing to do with food safety. They’re largely indicators of quality, not danger, and misunderstanding them leads millions of people to throw away perfectly edible groceries every year.
Why Food Labels Are So Confusing
Food dating isn’t standardized in the U.S. outside of infant formula, which is regulated. Everything else, from dairy to chips, follows voluntary guidelines created by manufacturers. That means companies choose the dates you see, usually based on when the product tastes or looks its best, not when it becomes unsafe to eat.
Because these terms sound official, shoppers assume they’re expiration dates. In reality, they function more like quality suggestions. A “Best By” stamp often simply indicates when the texture or flavor is at its peak. Once that window passes, the item may not be at its freshest, but that doesn’t mean it’s dangerous.
Confusion grows when brands use different labels inconsistently. One cereal box may feature “Use By,” another “Best Before,” and a third “Sell By,” all suggesting slightly different meanings. Without clear rules, consumers default to caution and end up over-discarding food.
Check out Why Weather Impacts What You Pay for Groceries to see how forecasts influence food costs.
Decoding the Big Three Labels
A few phrases appear most often in grocery aisles, and each has a distinct meaning:
“Best By” is the most consumer-friendly term and refers to optimal quality. Food is usually perfectly safe after this date, provided it has been stored properly. The taste or texture might shift a little, but it’s still usable.
“Sell By” is meant for stores, not shoppers. It tells retailers how long to display an item for inventory rotation. Many foods remain safe for days or weeks past this date, depending on the product.
“Use By” sounds the most serious, but except for infant formula, it still reflects quality rather than safety. It signals the last day the manufacturer guarantees peak freshness.
The key takeaway: none of these dates indicates when food becomes unsafe; proper handling and storage are far more important.
For another pricing factor, see Why Certain Stores Use Specific Lighting and How It Affects What You Spend.
How to Know When Food Is Actually Unsafe
While dates don’t dictate safety, your senses can guide you. Spoiled foods often show clear signs long before they pose a risk. Sour smells, discoloration, slimy textures, or off flavors indicate the food should be tossed. Mold also shows that an item is done, with a few exceptions, such as hard cheese, which can be salvaged by removing the affected portion.
For many foods, such as canned goods, dry pasta, rice, beans, and pantry snacks, the shelf life extends months or years beyond the printed date. High-acid canned foods, such as tomatoes, typically last around 18 months; low-acid items, like beans, can last 2–5 years if the can remains intact. Frozen foods remain safe indefinitely, although their texture may decline over time.
Refrigerated items require more attention. Milk, for instance, often lasts several days beyond its date. Eggs kept cold can remain fresh for 3 to 5 weeks. Meat and seafood spoil faster, but their smell and texture give fairly reliable cues.
When in doubt, look for the package condition. A swollen can or a leaking package is unsafe, no matter the date.
Explore The Surprising Science Behind Why You Overspend at Big Box Stores for insight into retail triggers.
How Understanding These Labels Saves Money
Misinterpreting food labels costs households money every month. Perfectly edible yogurt, bread, cheese, vegetables, canned goods, and snacks often end up in the trash because the printed date “expired.” For families on a budget, clearing up the confusion can dramatically reduce grocery spending.
You can also use “Best By” knowledge to shop smarter. Items near their printed date often get marked down, and because they’re still safe, these discounts can lead to significant savings. Stores frequently discount bakery bread, dairy, and prepared foods even when they have several days of quality life left.
Meal planning becomes easier, too. By knowing what’s actually perishable versus what looks “expired,” you can prioritize what needs to be cooked first, reducing last-minute food waste.
Understanding food labels also empowers you to push back against the instinct to overbuy. Instead of stocking up “just in case,” you can make confident decisions based on storage life and real food safety cues.
